This 2024 shortlist covers ten used cars, from sedans and SUVs to hybrids and EVs. Think of it as a starting point for researching specific models, not a guarantee that any individual car will be reliable.
When it comes to purchasing a used car, reliability isn't just a preference - it's a necessity. A reliable used car can spare you unexpected repair bills, give you peace of mind on the road, and hold its value better over time.
Reliability depends on the specific generation and powertrain, and on how the car has been maintained and used. Start with your budget and needs, then look into the model years and versions available to you.
The price ranges below are indicative 2024 figures, not current valuations: compare local listings and the condition of each car before making an offer.
The 2024 Model Selection
Choosing the best used cars for your needs means comparing specific models instead of assuming that every BMW, Toyota, Volvo or Mazda is equally reliable. The selection below covers ten models worth a closer look.
For each model, use the points below to guide your inspection and further research. Equipment and powertrains vary by year, trim and market.
10. Honda Accord
The Honda Accord is the sedan that took tenth place in our original selection. Check whether its passenger space and comfort suit the way you drive, then compare the service history and powertrain of the cars for sale on the used car market.
Model Years Discussed
- 2014–2017: Compare the engine, transmission and service history; specifications differ by market.
- 2018–2020: Check the exact version and which driver-assistance features are actually fitted, instead of going by the model year alone.
What to Check
- Engine and transmission: Go over the scheduled maintenance and look up known mileage reliability issues for this model before you book an inspection.
- Build quality: Durable construction, quality materials.
- Safety equipment: Confirm which driver-assistance systems the car has and make sure they work; availability varies by trim.
- Maintenance: Get quotes for any work coming due and check that parts and service are easy to find locally.
Indicative Prices (2024)
- 2014-2017 models: €12,000 - €17,000
- 2018-2020 models: €20,000 - €27,000
9. Toyota Corolla
The Toyota Corolla comes in gas and hybrid versions, depending on the year and market. Only the hybrids use regenerative braking to recover energy, so check which drivetrain the car you’re looking at has, along with its service history.
Model Years Discussed
- 2014-2016 (Eleventh Generation): Noted for reliability, with updated safety features.
- 2017–2020: Generation changes in this period happen at different times depending on body style and market. Confirm the exact version instead of assuming one generation covers all these years.
What to Check
- Specification: Compare the interior space, engine and transmission with what the paperwork says and what you need.
- Reliability surveys: Check which model years and engines a survey actually covers; a good overall score for the model doesn’t guarantee anything about an individual car.
- Owner feedback: Look for problems that come up again and again on this model, and find out whether they’ve been fixed on the car you’re looking at.
- 2019 examples: Check which driver-assistance features are fitted and whether any recalls or related service work have been done.
- Purchase decision: Weigh survey results together with maintenance records and an inspection. A numerical score with no source behind it is not proof of a car’s condition.
Indicative Prices (2024)
- 2014-2016 models: €14,350 - €17,050
- 2017-2020 models: €15,000 - €20,000
8. Škoda Kodiaq
Since its launch, the Skoda Kodiaq has gained a reputation for reliability, practicality, and value for money. The Kodiaq, like many Skoda models, benefits from Volkswagen Group's engineering, which contributes to its solid build quality and dependable performance.
Model Years Discussed
- 2017-2019 (First Generation): Praised for safety and comfort improvements.
- 2020–2021: Compare the engine, drivetrain and equipment with earlier versions; not every car from these years got the same updates.
What to Check
- Safety systems: Check whether features such as emergency braking and lane assist are fitted and working.
- Reliable powertrains: Offers efficient and durable engine options, providing a smooth and reliable driving experience.
- Ownership costs: Check the service schedule and get quotes for tires, brakes and any drivetrain work that’s due.
- All-wheel drive: Check whether this particular Kodiaq has it, and look at the related maintenance records.
Indicative Prices (2024)
- 2017-2019 models: €20,000 - €30,000
- 2020-2021 models: €30,000 - €40,000
7. Mazda CX-5
The Mazda CX-5 is acclaimed for its reliability, sporty performance, and premium feel within the compact SUV category, offering a compelling mix of style and substance. With its blend of reliability, engaging driving experience, and upscale interior, this car remains a top choice for those seeking a used compact SUV that doesn't compromise on performance or style.
Model Years Discussed
- 2016–2018: The CX-5 changed generations during this period, so confirm which generation and trim the car you’re viewing is.
- 2019-2021 (Second Generation): Introduces updated styling, enhanced safety features, and improved driving dynamics.
What to Check
- Driving performance: Stands out for its agile handling and responsive powertrains.
- Safety assessment: Look up the crash-test result for the right model and test year; one result doesn’t apply to every CX-5.
- Emergency braking: Find out which system this car has and what its limits are. Driver-assistance features can’t prevent every collision.
- Adaptive cruise control: Check whether the trim has it and make sure it works properly.
- Blind-spot and lane assistance: Check what’s actually fitted; these features aren’t standard on every version.
Indicative Prices (2024)
- 2016-2018 models: €15,000 - €20,000
- 2019-2021 models: €20,000 - €30,000
6. BMW 5 Series [G30]
The G30 BMW 5 Series is the executive sedan on this list. It came with a range of engines and trim levels, so compare each car’s spec, service history and likely running costs. Luxury features and newer tech don’t make a car reliable on their own.
Model Years Discussed
- 2017–2019 G30 models: For each car, check the engine, drivetrain, equipment and maintenance record.
What to Check
- Powertrain: Look into the specific engine and transmission; G30 versions differ quite a lot.
- Condition: Inspect the interior equipment and bodywork, and make sure any expensive optional features work.
- Safety equipment: Find out which driver-assistance systems the car has, check that they work and look for any recalls that apply.
- Technology: Test the connectivity and driver-assistance features one by one; extra equipment can also push up repair costs.
Indicative Prices (2024)
- 2017-2019 models: €25,000 - €40,000
5. Ford Mondeo
The Ford Mondeo is a roomy family car that came with a range of engines and body styles. The years below cover different versions, so compare the exact generation, powertrain and service needs.
Model Years Discussed
- 2013–2016: Check the generation and body style carefully; this period includes a model change in some markets.
- 2017–2020: Compare the specific engine, transmission and equipment, including whether the car is a hybrid.
What to Check
- Engine options: Offers a range of reliable engines, including eco-friendly hybrids, known for longevity.
- Build quality: Solid construction with quality materials contributes to its lasting durability.
- Driving dynamics: Balanced handling and comfortable ride quality ensure enduring performance.
- Drivetrain: Check whether the car is front-wheel drive or has the optional all-wheel drive.
- Repair budget: Get local quotes for the maintenance this car needs. A single fleet-average annual cost won’t give you a reliable budget for every Mondeo.
Indicative Prices (2024)
- 2013-2016 models: €8,000 - €12,000
- 2017-2020 models: €14,000 - €18,000
4. Volkswagen Touareg
The Volkswagen Touareg is a large SUV, and the years covered here include different generations and trim levels. Look at comfort and space, but also at the drivetrain, suspension, tires and expected running costs.
Model Years Discussed
- 2017-2020: These years represent the later years of the second generation and the introduction of the third generation, where you can expect updated technology, refined interiors, and enhanced performance features (R-Line, R-Line Plus).
What to Check
- R-Line equipment: Check the actual option list; wheel size, cameras and seat adjustment vary by year and market.
- Engine performance: Find out the exact engine output and transmission before comparing acceleration or fuel economy.
- Handling: Despite its size, the Touareg offers nimble and agile handling, with light yet precise steering.
- Space and comfort: Check the seating layout and trunk space for that generation, and see how they work for you in person.
Indicative Prices (2024)
- 2017-2018 models: €30,000 - €45,000
- 2019-2020 models: €40,000 - €60,000
3. Volvo S60
The Volvo S60 is the compact executive sedan on this list. Up against competition from German brands, it’s an alternative worth comparing on seating, equipment and powertrain options. Judge the individual car, and don’t assume its safety credentials mean it’s mechanically reliable.
Key Model Years
- 2016-2018 (Second Generation): Known for reliability, featuring significant updates and enhancements.
- 2019 onwards in the original shortlist (Third Generation): Marks the start of the latest generation with state-of-the-art technology and safety improvements.
What to Check
- R-Design and inscription trims: Offer sporty or luxurious options with features like lowered suspension and wood inlays.
- R-Design specification: Confirm wheel size, seats and driver-assistance equipment on the actual vehicle; the trim name alone doesn’t tell you which options are fitted.
- Polestar Engineered versions: Check the exact performance equipment and service requirements, since the spec differs by year and market.
- Driving experience: Delivers a firm ride with stiff sports suspension, more noticeable in city driving compared to rivals like Audi A4 and Jaguar XE.
Indicative Prices (2024)
- Models 2016-2018: 15 000 € - 25 000 €
- Models 2019 onwards in the original shortlist: 25 000 € - 40 000 €
2. Nissan Leaf
The Nissan Leaf is the battery-electric car in this selection. Range, charging capability and battery condition vary from version to version. Weigh them against your daily driving and access to charging, instead of relying on a general reputation for reliability.
Model Years Discussed
- 2015-2017 (First Generation): Offers a balance of range and value.
- 2018-2020 (Second Generation): Improved battery life and range, alongside technological upgrades.
What to Check
- Battery condition: Ask for a proper battery health check and compare the result with the car’s age, use and any remaining warranty.
- Owner evidence: Look for model-specific information and repair records; a satisfaction percentage with no source isn’t enough to prove reliability.
- Inspection: Check charging, cabin electronics, suspension and other systems as well as the traction battery.
- Simplified mechanics: Electric vehicles like the Leaf have fewer mechanical parts, reducing wear and potential problems.
- Powertrain condition: An electric drivetrain doesn’t rule out expensive repairs. Look into any warning messages and the service history before you buy.
Indicative Prices (2024)
- 2015-2017 models: €7,000 - €11,000
- 2018-2020 models: €18,000 - €24,000
1. Lexus NX 300h
Despite being marketed as an entry-level compact SUV by the Japanese manufacturer, the NX boasts features and qualities that surpass what one might expect from an introductory model.
The NX 300h combines a hybrid drivetrain with a compact SUV body style. It took first place in our original shortlist, but that doesn’t make it a verified ranking of every used luxury car. Check the maintenance and condition of the individual vehicle.
Model Years Discussed
- 2017-2020 (First Generation): Offers a balance of updated features and proven reliability. These years benefit from technological improvements and refined features, making them a solid choice for reliability and overall value.
What to Check
- Hybrid powertrain efficiency: The Lexus NX 300h features a highly efficient hybrid powertrain, offering a balance of power and fuel economy for long-term reliability.
- Build quality: Its durable build quality ensures that the vehicle can withstand the rigors of daily use while maintaining its integrity and performance over time.
- Safety technology: Confirm what’s fitted for that year and trim, and check for open recalls.
- Running costs: Compare the scheduled maintenance and likely repair costs for this particular car; a hybrid system doesn’t guarantee low costs.
Indicative Prices (2024)
- 2017-2020 models: €20,000 - €30,000
How to Use the Shortlist
These ten models cover different needs and ownership costs. Use the selection to narrow your research, then compare the exact model year, engine, equipment and maintenance record of each car.
The order reflects our editorial choice, not a scored ranking. Treat it as a starting point, and base your decision on the records, current prices and an independent inspection.
